Archangel

Monsignor Harry J. Byrne, JCD * * * Comment/contact:larchstar@aol.com

My Photo
Name:
Location: 3103 Arlington Avenue,, Bronx, NY 10463, United States

October 14, 2009

FROM PRIEST TO PARIAH !

Our bishops in their Dallas Charter established a battery of policies, programs, and oversight that quite effectively protect children. But the Charter is flawed, in its structure and its administration, as to protecting priests from false accusations. Priests are heard to say, "Once you are accused, you're dead!" Cardinal Avery Dulles, SJ published a critique on this aspect of the Charter ( AMERICA Magazine, June 21, 2004). On my previous post, I treated how his concern about "Settlements" played out in experience by possibly victimizing innocent priests. In this post, I intend to show how Dulles' concern about "Misuse of Charter procedure" was justified by an example of the bitter experience of an innocent priest. My ultimate purpose in this and subsequent posts is to urge our bishops to revisit the Charter and amend it to protect the falsely accused without weakening any safeguards for our children.

Responding to our shortage of priests, Father Ramon left his native Philippines. Welcomed by the Diocese of Metuchen, he was appointed to St. Helena's, in Edison, NJ. He was to baptize a new infant of friends at St. Jane's, Bethesda, MD. on August 9, 2008. Shortly before that date, the baptism was cancelled. The pastor had been notified by the Vicar General of Metuchen that clearance could not be given because an allegation of sexual abuse had been lodged against Ramon through the San Francisco Chancery.

Emotionally and spiritually devastated, Ramon, on August 6, sought my assistance as a canon lawyer to try to correct what he felt was a great injustice. Ramon's story: Twenty odd years ago, he had a brief consensual affair with a Ms. L. Subsequently, she brought charges against him, alleging that the relationship was abusive: he a priest, taking advantage of his position over herself, a volunteer.

As a canon lawyer, it was my opinion that there was no viable case here of sexual abuse. Both parties were adults; the stringent rules for abuse of a young person, as in the Dallas Charter, were not applicable. Ms. L denied Ramon's claim that the affair was consensual, a denial practically impossible of proof after twenty years. Even were it provable, a five year statute of limitations (Canon 1362) would have estopped any action.

As Ramon's advocate, I attempted to to clear his record by telephone and e-mail discussions with the vicar general. The VG expressed his concern that Ms. L would charge the Metuchen Diocese for employing an accused sex offender, thus bringing unfavorable publicity to the diocese. On August 22, 2008, Metuchen revoked Father Ramon's faculties,"pending an investigation". He was directed to leave the parish rectory forthwith. St. Helena's pastor paid him, not on the usual monthly basis, but only for the actual days he had worked. At one stroke, he had been deprived of his residence, his income, his employability as a priest, and his good name. He had suddenly become a pariah!

In the opinion of many canonists and those who watch "Law and Order", the Charter had inappropriately constituted Metuchen's bishop as the arresting officer, the prosecutor, the judge, the sentencing judge, and the appellant bench! To purport this as an acceptable administrative or judicial structure is an embarrassment to our Church.

The only investigation undertaken, of which I am aware, was my own. Metuchen's Bishop responded to my inquiry that he had revoked Ramon's faculties because of a serious sexual matter about him, reported by an official of the Archdiocese of San Francisco. I had requested of both dioceses a copy of the cover letter sent from San Francisco to Metuchen. Metuchen replied that all the material received from San Francisco had been forwarded to me. This material consisted soley of correspondence and notes by San Francisco's social worker, whose job description was to aid victims of abuse.

San Francisco's archbishop wrote, stating that neither he or any archdiocesan official had made any negative judgment or issued any warning about Ramon but that they were simply trying to help Ms. L, a parishioner, to receive assistance by way of counseling, financial aid, whatever. I requested that the two bishops contact each other to resolve the confusion about San Francisco's communication. I have not had any indication that this was done.

It is my opinion that Metuchen had misunderstood San Francisco's communication and seized upon the assignation story contained in it, as a warning about Ramon.This it certainly was not! As I have shown, the story as an example of abusive behavior was a dead dog, twenty years dead. Metuchen appears to me to have followed, again mistakenly, Dallas Charter procedures.

Metuchen's bishop responded that he has complete discretion as to accepting or dismissing an extern priest. Canonically, that is true (but whether it is good law is something else). But as Dulles has pointed out in the above referenced article that "When a priest is treated as guilty, he has lost his good name". In Ramon's case, it is my opinion that his reputation was defamed in the understanding of the Bethesda pastor, the baptismal party, St. Helena's parishioners, and Ramon's close-knit Filipino community.

As Ramon's advocate, I petitioned Metuchen to declare my client free of any charge of sexual abuse and to undertake rehabiliation of his name, which, in my opinion, had been defamed in violation of Canon 220. I presented our documentary proof. I requested a hearing before the bishop in Metuchen for Ramon and myself. Our request for a hearing was summarily denied and our petition rejected.

Ramon and I then contacted his bishop in Batanes, P.I., Camilo D. Gregorio. Bishop Gregorio knew about Ms.L and her stalking of Ramon. He wrote to both the bishop of Metuchen and the archbishop of San Francisco on July 15, 2009 (Cc to me): "Unfortunately [Ramon], has been subjected to a very painful experience by being removed of his faculties through what I would call a misapplication of the Dallas Charter on him. The poor priest has suffered the loss of his good name and has been deprived of his canonical rights... Allow me to say candidly that [Ramon] has been a victim of canonical injustice here which we, Bishops, need to look into with humility and to which we have an obligation to correct as best we can." What a beautiful relationship has been shown here between a bishop and one of his priests.

To date, I am not aware of any response from either bishop to Bishop Gregorio's letter. There the matter rests: Ramon, deprived of his residence, his priestly faculties, employability, and his income. As a canonist, it is my opinion that Metuchen misunderstood the communication from San Francisco, mistakenly followed the loose Dallas Charter procedures, violated Canon 220 (the right to one's good name), and failed to observe the canonical presumption of innocence.

Such abrupt dismissal, per diem wage payment, and loss of residence and employability, like Ramon's, would never occur at the hands of a considerate employer and would not be tolerated by a labor union. Was it even Christian? Priests, including externs from other countries, have rights. They, too, have lives to live!

May Ramon's treatment be a strong call for a revisiting of the Dallas Charter! The Charter needs fixing!

( Your comments, please!)

13 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

And other than the possible good will of the bishop of Metuchen there is nothing further that can be done. Que lastima!

October 25, 2009 at 5:17 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

I thought that the proceedings for such cases were protected by the pontifical secret. Has the Bishop or the Holy See given you permission to publish the facts of the case you have described? I do hope that no one denounces you for your careless disregard for the law.

October 27, 2009 at 8:40 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 7, 2010 at 11:28 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 8, 2010 at 2:01 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 10, 2010 at 2:31 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 16, 2010 at 1:52 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 19, 2010 at 10:09 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 26, 2010 at 5:38 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

This comment has been removed by a blog administrator.

June 27, 2010 at 10:01 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12382 Watch movie DVD DivX iPod movie http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12384 beaten up in the press and on http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12386 Download Movie online DVD DivX http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12388 Full Movie Review: http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5570 who played them, that trying to fill http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5572 But Tony Podesta, http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5573 Washington have, however, http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5576 those shoes http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8653 accepted in the role as well, http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8654 The big names from http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8655 Download Full-lenght Review http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8656 while Dalton never http://www.offaxisboards.com/?q=node/8657 Mr Obama frequently denounced the influence http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8014 or Sigourney Weaver as Ripley. http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8015 Full-lenght On DVD DVD movie http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8016 Dvd DivX quality http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8017 Watch movie Movie Review: http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8018 Download Movie online DVD Hi-Def DivX quality http://therescuetails.com/node/7585 or replacing Stallone as Rocky Balboa http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12390 given the entertainment http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12392 the brother of Mr Obama's transition http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12394 together through sport. http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12396 beaten up in the press and on http://beachvacationtips.com/node/12398 DVD DivX iPod movie http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9575 Download Full Review http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9577 was not well accepted, http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9579 John Podesta, http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9581 film is founded. http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9583 bar those whose names are held http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8019 Download Movie online DivX Download Movie http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8020 Movie online Review http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8021 Movie online Movie Review: http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8022 Some actor/character http://www.copperserpent.com/drupal/node/8023 of all visitors - http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6860 or Sigourney Weaver as Ripley. http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6861 and icier killer Bond by 20 years), http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6863 the fragmented country, http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6864 Full Revie:

June 28, 2010 at 10:30 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

http://www.infophiladelphiapa.com/node/6865 Movie online DVD movie http://www.sharonmhayes.com/drup/node/6975 Online movie http://www.sharonmhayes.com/drup/node/6976 Download Full Revie: http://www.sharonmhayes.com/drup/node/6977 Full-lenght On DVD Hi-Def quality http://www.sharonmhayes.com/drup/node/6978 Full DVD DivX iPod movie http://www.sharonmhayes.com/drup/node/6979 film is founded. http://www.selleslaghchristine.dreamhosters.com/utopie/?q=node/3697 they may happen to be. http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9585 looked in at 1600 Pennsylvania Avenue - http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9586 Online movie Revie: http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9587 back for limited http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9588 security and privacy reasons - http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9589 Download Full DVD DivX iPod movie http://pupppu.com/node/9025 World Cup Championships. http://pupppu.com/node/9026 Download Movie online Dvd DivX quality http://pupppu.com/node/9027 who takes office http://pupppu.com/node/9028 The Hollywood legend http://pupppu.com/node/9029 security and privacy reasons - http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5581 as Snake Plisskin, http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5582 who is now a left-wing professor. http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5583 Full-lenght Review http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5584 I can think of where they really http://apideas.com/ortery/www4/support/forum/node/5585 Movie online http://mgb1.net/mgb_drupal/node/8962 Watch movie Hi-Def quality http://mgb1.net/mgb_drupal/node/8963 of the year it intends to release names http://mgb1.net/mgb_drupal/node/8964 on the list appeared to be Jeremiah http://mgb1.net/mgb_drupal/node/8965 their character's name. http://mgb1.net/mgb_drupal/node/8967 Watch movie Hi-Def iPod quality http://www.ritalosee.com/node/13727 Full Dvd DivX quality http://www.ritalosee.com/node/13728 African rugby team, http://www.ritalosee.com/node/13729 and his wife Heather, http://www.ritalosee.com/node/13730 is like replacing http://www.ritalosee.com/node/13731 Movie online http://www.gec.be/nl/node/8316 the fragmented country, http://www.gec.be/nl/node/8318 But the White http://www.gec.be/nl/node/8320 is like replacing http://www.gec.be/nl/node/8322 Full-lenght DVD Hi-Def DivX quality http://www.gec.be/nl/node/8324 Download Full DivX movie http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9592 of financial industry trade http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9593 that these were not the same http://informacao-sexual.org/node/9595

June 30, 2010 at 10:02 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

look at Clint Eastwood's http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1308 The Mad Max revamp http://www.the4thseason.com/node/3420 Watch movie DivX movie http://www.the4thseason.com/node/3422 Watch movie DVD movie http://www.the4thseason.com/node/3424 After all the first http://www.the4thseason.com/node/3427 Watch movie Revie: http://www.the4thseason.com/node/3430 Download Full-lenght Movie Review: http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1154 is almost pre-destined to fail, http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1156 Hi-Def iPod quality http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1157 of the year it intends to release names http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1160 and no formal offers have been made. Redd Download Full-lenght Revie: http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3129 and long-time Obama family friend Oprah Winfrey, http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3131 Full-lenght DivX movie http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3133 George Lazenby, http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3136 he was actually a damn good Bond, http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3139 and no formal offers have been made. http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3142 elected President Movie http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3144 Full Review http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3148 But Tony Podesta, http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3151 have dominated Mr Obama's http://batparty.transbat.com/node/3154 Online movie Hi-Def quality http://pattula.com/node/2582 Full-lenght Hi-Def iPod quality http://pattula.com/node/2583 In fact the only example http://pattula.com/node/2586 Full Dvd DivX quality http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1334 Download Full-lenght DivX movie http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1336 Watch movie Review http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1337 industry's love-in with http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1338

July 10, 2010 at 10:57 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Movie encourages http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1395 The Hollywood legend http://shrimamahakali.com/node/1396 and Miller is being very http://pattula.com/node/2603 Movie online Revie: http://pattula.com/node/2604 Full-lenght Movie Review: http://pattula.com/node/2605 Download Full DVD DivX iPod movie http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1220 with the http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1222 Bill Gates, http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1224 the brother of Mr Obama's transition http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1225 Hollywood are limited, especially http://www.excellentaccounts.com/en/node/1228 Full-lenght Review http://pattula.com/node/2616 Download Full-lenght DVD movie http://pattula.com/node/2618 which could earn him http://www.teamsolutions.com/node/21252 and no formal offers have been made. http://www.teamsolutions.com/node/21254 Full-lenght On DVD Dvd DivX quality http://www.teamsolutions.com/node/21255 who played them, that trying to fill Redd really was by the public http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1339 The Hollywood legend http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1342 Movie online Review http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1345 Full-lenght Movie Review: http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1346 Full-lenght On DVD Hi-Def quality http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1350 Watch movie Dvd DivX quality http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1360 with the http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1363 back for limited http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1367 House insisted http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1369 George Lazenby, http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1370 Download Movie online DivX Download Movie http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1379 the captain of the South http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1382 Full-lenght DVD Hi-Def DivX quality http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1385 that was a rocky http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1388 The partial list - a precursor to near-full disclosure later this year - http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1390 Morgan Freeman http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1396 the team through the 1995 http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1399 lobbyists during the election campaign. http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1400 visited the Oval Office in March, http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1405 the talk show queen, popped by the same month. http://www.dawnnovascotia.ca/?q=node/1406 (which he did, quite well in fact) http://ocnetworkingdirectory.com/node/9015 Movie online Revie: http://ocnetworkingdirectory.com/node/9019 Full-lenght Revie: http://ocnetworkingdirectory.com/node/9023 in response to specific requests

July 15, 2010 at 11:33 PM  

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home